Restaurant Review – Antoni’s Italian Café Lafayette, LA

Restaurant Review of Antoni’s Italian Café

1118 Coolidge St. A, Lafayette, LA  70503


Rating: (1-10)

1 – Poor, 3 – Below Average and Needs Much Improvement,

5 – Average but Needs Improvement, 7 – Above Average and Acceptable,

8 and 9 – Superior, 10 – Exceptional and Could Not Have Been Better!

I didn’t indicate the intention to review our dining experience.  We paid for our meal in full.  A guest feedback card was delivered with the check after our meal and I indicated the website to access the review and suggestions.

Atmosphere:  10

There is a quaint outside patio at the entrance that would be a wonderful seating area on a cool day or evening.  In any case, it serves as a garden entrance adding to the exterior as this location is an older shopping plaza that is both well-kept and fully leased.  Inside, the smells were fresh, clean and welcoming.  Customers were sporting dressy casual and casual attire   Our visit was on a Saturday, July 14, 2018 at 8:00 PM.  Patrons were couples out for a Saturday evening date night, a large table of couples socializing and several tables of families with children ranging in age, all of which seemed used to dining in nicer restaurants that expect children all well-mannered.    The atmosphere was pleasurable in every way.

Interior Design:  10

Quaint and well done, décor is tasteful, Italian theme and pleasant.  The lighting was exceptionally well done, very difficult to accomplish.  The subtleties indicated a standard of care with owners who are engaged and personally invested in the restaurant.  This restaurant is neat and meticulously clean which frankly is hard to find.

was just right.  Chris and Casey ordered water with their meal and I ordered a Bloody Mary.  This drink was seasoned well without so much floating that it was sandy to drink and beautifully garnished with olives and okra.  When I inquired, the waiter a New Orleans Catrina transplant, offered that the Bloody Mary’s are really good.  He was absolutely correct.  Sunday brunch would beg for a Bloody Mary.  Chris and Casey ordered dessert; Chris the triple chocolate cheese cake and Casey the tiramisu both were fresh and each was presented beautifully.

Menu Options:  9

Menu options are diverse including; fish, chicken, meat, pasta and pizza.  Also, widely available were vegetables as side dishes, salads and vegetable options on pasta and pizza.  The wine list is extensive are is the list of suggested cocktails.  The dessert menu is perfect for an Italian café all made on the premises.

Presentation:  10

The appearance of the food when plated and served was exceptional.  The professionalism of the staff presentation was superior as well.

Service:  10

The service that we received was superior!  We were greeted at the door by a host that gave us a strong message of superior service.  David, clearly a professional knew just how to enhance our experience and how to make us want to be served by him again.  He delivered service that was thoughtful, appropriate and thorough, hard to explain at the level of excellence that this was delivered at but exceptional when seen.

Cost and Value:  10

We had one cocktail, 3 salads, 3 entrees and 2 deserts for $63.  We ordered what we wanted and the bill was most reasonable.  The value for what we received was incredible.  These are reasonable portion sizes.  They are not huge which frankly we dislike.  We ate our meal without left overs and we actually wanted and felt we had permission to enjoy a desert.  I must admit, this was a nice feeling and we were not stuffed, uncomfortable but completely satisfied.  What more could you ask for, right?


We want the great restaurants to be supported and found.  This ensures that when we return, these choices will still be available and it ensure that the those in your area will have All Good options to choose from.  With this in mind, the largest growth area in the food and restaurant business is an opportunity and as such we feel the need to explain further so that the owners of Antoni’s Italian Café can indeed capitalize from this exposure and prevent a missed opportunity.  We are near vegan vegetarian and the menu doesn’t have a vegetarian section.  In addition, the vegetables that we visually saw were exceptional; asparagus, broccoli and a wide variety of salad choices not to mention all kinds of vegetable choices that can be added to the pizza and pasta dishes.  So, upon re-printing the menu, there would be every reason to have a vegetarian section when you have so many wonderful options to choose from.  Most important, searching the restaurants in Lafayette for a vegan vegetarian option or even for restaurants that have vegetables available on the menu proves that this would separate your business from the others and set you apart in a category of food and restaurant service that is most growing in the US and Internationally.  In a college town with educators and students, this option is very important.  As a small city with a history and prevalence of heart disease, options for those who need to change their diet are also important.  Last suggestion, the beer and craft beer list are lacking and doesn’t meet the market demand of present day.  This is also a growth area within the industry.  Although this would require a change, it adding just a few of the most in demand by beer category would be a nice additional offering.

Overall Rating and Assessment:  9.86

We highly recommend this restaurant.  The atmosphere, service, cost/value make this a restaurant to add to your routine restaurant outings list in Lafayette, LA.  It is also a fantastic place to take your large party for a special occasion.  If you live nearby, we sincerely hope that you choose to support this local, fresh, Italian Café because we think it is truly ALL GOOD.

Amanda Griesdorn


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: